GoHotelly
2-star hotel

Carlton House Hotel

Experience a quiet and comfortable stay at Carlton House Hotel, conveniently located in Watertown, WI. Enjoy recently updated rooms, caring management, secure premises, and a friendly community. Ideal for business travelers and visitors seeking affordable

115 S 1st St, Watertown, WI 53094, United States View on map
6.4/10
Average Based on 53 recent guest reviews
What recent guests emphasize

Mixed experiences with strong management and value

Recent guests highlight the property's affordability, clean and quiet rooms, and attentive management, while noting some practical limitations due to the building's age and shared facilities.

Guests often praise

  • Friendly, helpful, and responsive management and landlord, especially Kari and Jeff.
  • Clean and quiet rooms with regular professional cleaning.
  • Affordable rates offering good value for those seeking budget accommodations.
  • Safe and secure building access, especially during evening hours.
  • Supportive community atmosphere with respectful and welcoming residents.

Worth knowing

  • Some rooms have shared bathrooms; private bathrooms and kitchens are limited.
  • The building is older, which can lead to inconsistent heating in winter and no air conditioning in summer.
  • Not a traditional hotel experience—more of a budget rooming house without typical hotel amenities like a pool or arcade.
  • Management enforces rules clearly, which may feel strict but aims to maintain order and safety.
  • Parking is generally not an issue for guests.

Best for

  • Travelers and visitors looking for affordable, basic accommodations in a friendly environment.
  • Guests comfortable with shared bathroom facilities or seeking housing alternatives.
  • Individuals needing temporary housing or a supportive community setting.
  • Those prioritizing cleanliness, quietness, and safety over luxury amenities.
  • Visitors planning to explore nearby parks and local historical sites.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Carlton House Hotel

The Carlton House Hotel, nestled in the heart of Watertown, Wisconsin, offers a distinctive lodging experience that balances affordability, comfort, and community spirit. With a rating of 3.2, this establishment stands out not for luxury, but for its welcoming atmosphere and practical amenities ideal for visitors seeking a quiet and safe place to stay.

Rooms at the Carlton House have been recently renovated, reflecting a thoughtful commitment to cleanliness and modern upkeep. Guests have expressed appreciation for the quiet environment and respectfulness among neighbors, a testament to the hotel's strong sense of community. The professional cleaning crew maintains high standards, visiting multiple times per week to ensure rooms remain fresh and inviting.

Management at the Carlton House Hotel, led by Kari, plays a pivotal role in the hotel's positive reputation. Kari’s approachable nature and hands-on management style foster trust and support, especially for guests facing challenging situations. Her readiness to assist with rent accommodations and community resources highlights a rare level of landlord empathy that goes beyond typical hotel service.

The hotel’s setup as a rooming house, with some units offering private bathrooms and kitchens, reflects flexible living arrangements catering to a diverse clientele. While it does not provide the recreational luxuries of larger hotels—such as pools or arcades—it excels in offering a safe, secure, and friendly environment for short or extended stays. The secured evening entrance enhances guest safety, contributing to peace of mind throughout the visit.

Carlton House Hotel’s strategic location at 115 S 1st St makes it an excellent base for sightseeing and recreation in Watertown. Guests appreciate the ease of access to local attractions and the convenience of nearby amenities suited to business travelers and leisure guests alike.

In essence, the Carlton House Hotel serves as more than just a place to rest; it is a supportive community hub that meets guests' essential needs with dignity and care. Its combination of affordable, clean rooms, dependable management, and a respectful tenant community makes it a strong recommendation for those seeking stability and refuge, especially in times of transition. For travelers valuing quiet comfort and genuine care, Carlton House Hotel is a reliable choice.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

JC
Jon C Dec 28, 2025
10

I found the rooms to be nice and quiet, my neighbors respectful, and the manager was amazing! I had to stay here for two weeks, and I haven't noticed one problem here. The rooms have recently been redone and there's a professional cleaning crew that comes in a few times a week. You won't find a better deal around!

NBN
North by Northwest Adventures Dec 18, 2025
10

Moved in over a year ago. Have had very little problems. When I first moved in it was a little different sharing a bathroom with others as I have never had to before. I got over that pretty quickly. There are rooms that you have your own bathroom and kitchen and I just like my little room a lot, so I decided not to move into a bath/ bed/ kitchen. Everybody that’s there is super friendly and will do anything to help each other out. When a problem resident comes in. They are very quick to get the issue solved or to get the resident removed or have the resident remove themselves.In this economy the expense for what you get is amazing here. I really do enjoy this building. If I had anything negative to say it would be that the buildings old enough that it doesn’t regulate heat very well. So sometimes it’s really hot in her during the winter but in reality it’s pretty easy to deal with. The owner, Jeff and manager Kerri are great to work with. Again I highly recommend this place if you’re looking for an affordable housing option without children.

JH
Jon Hardy Nov 24, 2025
8.0

Clean, quiet, and comfortable. Saw a lot of negative reviews on the management and their rules. First of all the rules are explained to you at the beginning. It's like any other Motel or Hotel, they have rules. Remember, this is a 'rooming house ' not the Motel 8. No pool, no arcade for children. If you need a place to lay your head I would recommend it.

FW
Flat Water Nov 16, 2025
10

I hit a rough patch in my life and I was unable to find rent elsewhere in a short period of time. Almost went homeless. Kari gave me a chance to get back on my feet and I'm forever grateful to her for that! I stayed there for a year and was able to move in to a house recently. I actually got comfortable living there and would recommend it to anyone who needs shelter when in need. The people I encountered were friendly for the most part and Kari is willing to accommodate. You get a fridge, bed, couch, and atleast a sink in your room. Some rooms have a bathroom, otherwise you will need to use a communal bathroom which didn't bother a person like myself. My only gripe was no AC in the summer but good heat in the winter. Parking was never an issue for me as well. A lot of the reviews on here are from before the change of management, and the place has since improved from what I've seen and is reasonably priced for what it is. Thank you Kari for helping me when no one else would!

KE
Kate Erickson Nov 14, 2025
10

Great place to stay, room and nice and affordable! Everyone very nice and welcoming and respectful. The rooms and very homey and cute! The manger Kari is just the best, she will help with anything you need, and has really tuned the place around inside and out! Have really enjoyed my stay since day 1! -k

DG
Dove-Whisper Grimmenga Oct 28, 2025
10

Kari is very nice. And is always willing to work with u when it comes to rent and helping you get assistance when u need help with the bills. 99% of the tendency are very nice. If there is ever someone bothering you. She deals with the situation immediately. She's great to have as a landlord. If your ever struggling to get housing this is a good place to start off.

RT
Robert Tessen Oct 17, 2025
10

I've been staying here for a few months now, it has had new ownership and management for about 5 years from what I understand. The management makes sure the property is clean and in a safe manner. I appreciate that during the evening hours entrance to the building is secured. Management has always been respectful and helpful in many ways. I would recommend this property to anyone.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Carlton House Hotel

Watertown, Wisconsin, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport 58 min Car
  • Dane County Regional Airport 48 min Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Aztalan State Park 764 reviews

Aztalan State Park

N6200 County Rd Q, Jefferson, WI 53549, United States

4.6 · State Park
Octagon House Museum 238 reviews

Octagon House Museum

919 Charles St, Watertown, WI 53094, United States

4.7 · Museum
Riverside Park 446 reviews

Riverside Park

916 Labaree St, Watertown, WI 53098, United States

4.6 · Park
People also viewed

Similar Hotels in Wisconsin

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

130 Plymouth St, Santa Cruz, CA 95060, United States

National 9 Motel

National 9 Motel offers clean rooms, free WiFi, and friendly service steps from the Santa Cruz Museum of Art & History and Beach ...

3.7 (305) View
1324 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

Arena Hotel

Experience friendly service and a convenient Brooklyn location at Arena Hotel. Enjoy clean rooms, free WiFi, complimentary breakf...

4.1 (810) View
2555 E 4th St, Reno, NV 89512, United States

Gold Coin Motel

Experience a quiet, familyowned motel in Reno with free WiFi and parking. Gold Coin Motel offers classic charm, essential amenit...

2.8 (42) View
737 S Orange Blossom Trl #3143, Orlando, FL 32805, United States

Orange Inn Motel

Experience a clean and welcoming stay at Orange Inn Motel, located on S Orange Blossom Trail, Orlando. Enjoy free WiFi, free park...

3.2 (211) View
4647 W Irlo Bronson Memorial Hwy, Kissimmee, FL 34746, United States

Maple Leaf Inn & Suites

Experience comfort and convenience at Maple Leaf Inn & Suites, located in Kissimmee, FL. Enjoy clean rooms, free WiFi, free parki...

3.6 (38) View
1010 6th St, Okeechobee, FL 34974, United States

Angler's Waterfront Motel

Discover Angler's Waterfront Motel in Okeechobee, FL, a clean and friendly waterfront motel perfect for families. Enjoy peaceful v...

3.9 (23) View
2637 Co Rd 99W, Willows, CA 95988, United States

Blue Gum Motel

Experience a peaceful, budgetfriendly stay at Blue Gum Motel in Willows, CA. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, a petfriendly environmen...

3.3 (104) View
1709 N Lynn Riggs Blvd, Claremore, OK 74017, United States

Claremore Motor Inn

Experience affordable comfort at Claremore Motor Inn, located on N Lynn Riggs Blvd. Enjoy free WiFi, breakfast, air conditioning,...

3.4 (171) View
1234 Lincoln Hwy, Schererville, IN 46375, United States

Motel Lee

Discover Motel Lee, a 3star budget hotel located on Lincoln Hwy in Schererville. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, modern remodeled bath...

3 (63) View
1310 W Main St, Mesa, AZ 85201, United States

Rawls Motel

Rawls Motel in Mesa, AZ offers clean, comfortable rooms with free WiFi and parking. Enjoy attentive staff, upgraded bathrooms, an...

2.9 (197) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Carlton House Hotel? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.